I went to a new (for me) thrift store to look for creepy looking candle holders, and I found the perfect ones! They were $2.00 each, which is a bit more than I would usually like to spend on such things in a thrift store, but they had so much potential!
I brought them home and spray-painted them an antique silver color and then distressed them with black paint and a sponge brush. I found these cool black candles at HL (Hobby Lobby, of course!) and used another candle to drip wax down it so I didn't ruin the cool tapered top. Man I love Halloween!